STAYING OR LEAVING FLOOD-PRONE AREAS (FPAs)? COMMUNITIES’ DECISION-MAKING AND ADAPTATION PATHWAYS IN THE MAHAKAM CASCADE LAKES (MCL), INDONESIA
Planning Malaysia , Vol. 24 (4) · 2026
Summary
Relocation should be integrated within a holistic framework that balances risk reduction with economic and sociocultural sustainability, supported by community participation to enhance resilience in flood-prone settlements.
Details
Abstract
The decision to move or stay in FPAs is crucial and impacts livelihood sustainability (LS). This study investigates household decisions to stay or relocate in flood-prone communities around the MCL in Indonesia and analyzes how these choices shape adaptation strategies. Drawing on qualitative data from in-depth interviews with residents of Pela Village (PV) (original settlement) and Sangkuliman Village (SV) (relocation site), the study reveals that the interplay of flood risk perception (FRP), place attachment (PA), and livelihood security (LSc) influences decisions. Communities remaining in PV have normalized flooding and are investing in structural adaptations, such as elevating house foundations to sustain their livelihoods and social ties. Conversely, relocated communities prioritize flood safety but face new challenges related to livelihood access and economic burden. Both groups exhibited active adaptive capacities and a willingness to bear adaptation costs, highlighting adaptation as a continuous process rather than a one-time response. The findings emphasize that relocation should be integrated within a holistic framework that balances risk reduction with economic and sociocultural sustainability, supported by community participation to enhance resilience in flood-prone settlements. © 2026 by MIP
Affiliations
Doctoral Geography Education Study Program Department of Geography, Faculty of Social Science, STATE UNIVERSITY OF MALANG, MALANG, Indonesia; Department of Geography Education, Faculty of Teacher Training Education, MULAWARMAN UNIVERSITY, SAMARINDA, Indonesia; Department of Geography, Faculty of Social Science, STATE UNIVERSITY OF MALANG, MALANG, Indonesia; Department of Physics, Faculty of Mathematics and Science, MULAWARMAN UNIVERSITY, SAMARINDA, Indonesia